3rd pillar: 3A or 3B?

What’s best for me? 3rd pillar 3A or 3B?

These two savings solutions are similar in several respects mbut there are crucial crucial differences interms of freedom, taxation and inheritance..

In general if you don’t already have a 3rd pillar,  it’s probably the 3A that you needbecause it’s tax-deductible everywhere, and therefore more attractive from a tax point of view.

However, there are cases where 3B may be preferable for example:
 – Passing the benefit on to someone other than yourself
 – In the event of the death of a person who is neither your child nor your spouse
 – Be able to withdraw the amount at any time, without having to meet any of the 3A withdrawal conditions
 – Save more than 3A amounts

In the cantons of Geneva and Fribourg, it’s not uncommon to do both, as 3B is also deductible up to a certain amount.

The following table summarizes the main differences between Pillar 3A and Pillar 3B: 

3A

  • Tax-deductible anywhere in Switzerland
  • Up to 7,056.00 per year (588.00 per month)
  • Allows indirect amortization (real estate)
  • No wealth tax
  • Taxed at reduced rate on withdrawal
  • Withdrawal conditions (retirement, housing, etc.)
  •  
Recommended

3B

  • No maximum amount
  • Unrestricted beneficiary clause (inheritance)
  • No withdrawal conditions
  • Deductible in Geneva (2,200.-) and Fribourg (750.-)
  • No tax on withdrawal
  • Taxed on wealth
  •  

Our 3rd pillar comparator

We have created a neutral, free online comparator that allows you to compare all 3rd pillar 3A and 3B solutions in just a few minutes.

What’s more, at the end of the process we offer you a free telephone appointment with one of our expert pension advisors, who will give you a personalized explanation of the advantages and disadvantages of each solution!

Farmin Qiu
Farmin Qiu
November 20, 2024
I used this service to get advice on the third pillar and would recommend them without hesitation.

I got in touch with David who was very transparent and efficient.

I like his style and appreciate his time.
Denis Thioly
Denis Thioly
November 15, 2024
Dear Mr Marchand,

Thank you for your very efficient and fast work.

your kindness and positive mood are much appreciated.

Yours faithfully Denis Thioly
V T
V T
November 7, 2024
I have concluded my agreement with the support of Mr. David Bolognesi.

Always ready to provide support and further explanations.
Vincent David
Vincent David
October 21, 2024
Mr. Xavier Hamo of Sparta Group gave me excellent advice.

His explanations were clear and understandable.
Geoffrey Soussi
Geoffrey Soussi
October 8, 2024
Mr Gaëtan Pembele has given me excellent advice and guidance on the various aspects of the 3rd pillar.

He has been indispensable and inspires the confidence and sympathy I would expect from an advisor.
Rashmi Chopra
Rashmi Chopra
August 8, 2024
Excellent and trustworthy, I highly recommend Mr. David Bolognesi.

I've never seen a more diplomatic, competent and hard-working professional in this field than him.
Jessica Esteves
Jessica Esteves
June 28, 2024
I'd be happy to recommend Mr Pembele as my pension advisor.

I really appreciated his availability and responsiveness.
Karolane Saint-Félix
Karolane Saint-Félix
May 9, 2024
Excellent service! We recommend it!

Personalized service and fast turnaround. I am delighted!

Thanks for everything Xavier 🙂
Albert G. Baliarda
Albert G. Baliarda
December 29, 2023
It was all free of charge, even if the end products I was interested in weren't from Groupe Sparta.

I'd certainly recommend their service.
Simone Curtet
Simone Curtet
April 30, 2024
Friendliness and competence sum up the discussions and advice I received from Xavier.

Thank you very much.
Albert G. Baliarda
Albert G. Baliarda
December 29, 2023
I was offered free, independent, personalized advice following a simulation I had carried out myself on the site, and that's exactly what I got.
Biofa aka
Biofa aka
December 8, 2023
Many thanks for Gaëtan's advice, which has been invaluable for my financial future.

I highly recommend SpartaGroup's services
Biofa aka
Biofa aka
December 8, 2023
Super, very useful and pleasant to deal with.
Drbi 77
Drbi 77
December 7, 2023
Super, effective advice without pushing in either direction, attentive and reliable.
J M
J M
December 2, 2023
Great experience talking to D. Bolognesi. Very professional and straightforward advice. Thank you!
Blanco Juan
Blanco Juan
November 25, 2023
Neutral advice provided by David, without trying to push anything, adapted to my situation. Much appreciated.
Blanco Juan
Blanco Juan
November 25, 2023
Brokers who stand out from the crowd ... Remarkable! Many thanks for your invaluable advice, your professionalism is a credit to you!
Tarkhovski
Tarkhovski
November 20, 2023
Excellent advice, Mr Hamo's explanations were very clear and relevant to my situation and needs.
Joana R. Ribeiro
Joana R. Ribeiro
November 13, 2023
I absolutely recommend the clear explanations, transparent and personalized advice for the preparation of a pension plan. ...
Aurélie Chalverat
Aurélie Chalverat
November 11, 2023
Mr Hamo gave me excellent advice on my third pillar. Cordial and constructive, the discussions always took into account my specific needs. ...
Alvise Cenere
Alvise Cenere
November 4, 2023
I've used this service to get advice on the third pillar and would recommend them without hesitation. I got in touch with David, who was very transparent and efficient, and gave me a clear overview of my options.
Irène Overney
Irène Overney
October 18, 2023
Our advisors are highly responsive and fully aware of the different options and constraints that apply to their customers' profiles. I highly recommend their services.

We’ll be with you every step of the way, free of charge, and beyond.